The Vick Breakdown
Monday, July 27th, 2009Unless you have been living under a rock, you are aware of the situation with Michael Vick and his conviction for the part in played in dog fighting. Now that he is out of jail, and not under house arrest, NFL commissioner Roger Goodell has ruled on whether Vick can continue his NFL career.
1. Vick can immediately take part in preseason practices, workouts and meetings and can play in the final two preseason games — if he can find a team that will sign him.
2. Once the season begins, Vick may participate in all team activities except games, and Goodell said he would consider Vick for full reinstatement by Week 6 (Oct. 18-19) at the latest.
So Vick isn’t suspended from the league, kind of. The “Commish” still has control; his heavy-hand is going a bit overboard in my eyes.
I know the NFL has player conduct and/or morals clauses, but why does this even matter? If you have a field, a football and 22 guys, Michael Vick is one of the most elite human beings on the planet. THE END. No extra yardage, or touchdowns, are scored for being a good human being, but it seems like that is what we expect of professional athletes. Right or wrong (we will get to that) Vick plays a violent sport where physical contact is the norm, yet he is expected to be a role model off the field. I would like to know who decided this and what they were thinking at the time? Why is an elite athlete someone we should look to as a guide to moral behavior? If you haven’t done so before, spend some time with someone who is among the elite in their given field. Many times, that is about all they have to offer – sort of like having all their eggs in one (extraordinary) basket.
The Argument About The Punishment
They were just dogs.
Many people feel like this shouldn’t be a big deal because they were just dogs. I’m not necessarily a dog person, but I’m not a monkey, donkey, pig, hamster, moose or bear person either. Somewhere along the line, dogs were elevated, in the animal kingdom, and became protected by human beings. Hey, it is a law so whatever.
The part that rubs me the wrong way is the fact that Roger Goodell thinks the judicial system isn’t equiped to punish Vick and he must pile on his own punishment. Additionally, he can’t just let him back in the league; he has to regulate how much Vick is allowed to participate and then has the nerve to pass it off as something for Vick’s own good. I would like to know if we should start worshipping Goodell because he is acting like he is God returned to earth. Dude, you run a football league. I know some “money” people may get offended by the “Thugs” in your league, but they don’t mind when those same players are making them a ton of money.
Let’s talk about Donte Stallworth. Stallworth killed a man while under the influence and recieved 24 whole days in jail and a lifetime ban from driving. Oh, and he suspended indefinately by Goodell. I thought the two sentences were way out of whack, but I have learned more about Stallworth’s situation.
1. Stallworth did not drive himself home. He took a cab or was driven home, went to sleep for a few hours and got up to get something to eat. He had basically slept part of his drunken state off although he probably thought he was OK to drive.
2. Stallworth was cooperative with the police. He was the one who called them.
3. The man he hit, and killed, was not using a cross walk. In fact, I read that Stallworth would have hit and killed him if he was totally sober.
4. The family didn’t want Stallworth to have a greater punishment. However, they were OK with the money he gave them.
After reading more about the Stallworth case, I’m not willing to say Vick’s sentence was extreme in comparison. What I am more inclined to say is that they are comparing apples to oranges. If he did sleep for a while before driving and would have killed the man sober makes a difference to me. I still have to process how much of a difference, but it is enough of a difference for me to say it isn’t the same as Vick.
Vick Can (kind of) Come Out To Play
Kathy, from www.kleverkathy.com, recently wrote an article about whether Michael Vick can come out to play. I guess the commissioner, in his controlling way, has said Vick can indeed come out to play. He just can’t play when it counts yet.




